Notes on: Kelley, N, Khan, O, Sharrock S (2017).
Racial prejudice in Britain today. NatCen.
Social research that works for society. Runnymede
Trust. https://www.runnymedetrust.org/publications/racial-prejudice-in-britain-today
Dave Harris
There has been a long trend of social
liberalisation affecting sex and sexual behaviour
as well, and the long-term trend, uncovered by the
British Social Attitudes Survey shows people
thinking that racial prejudice 'has been on the
increase or unchanged and (with the exception of
1991) have predicted a continuation of that trend
when asked to look to the future. It seems likely
that this picture is the result of both increasing
awareness and decreasing social tolerance of
racial prejudice' (5) [absolute figures vary
between 50 and 40% of those thinking there is more
racial prejudice now, about the same thinking
about the same, and 15 to 20% thinking less]. When
asking whether they consider themselves very
prejudiced a little prejudiced or not prejudiced,
more than 60% said they were not prejudiced, and
about 40% said prejudiced, although 'there is good
reason to assume that the actual proportion of the
British public who are racially prejudiced may be
higher' (6).
'26% of respondents described themselves as 'very"
or "a little" racially prejudiced' [only 1% in the
first category, 25% a little, and everyone else
not prejudiced at all]. There seemed
'statistically significant relationships in three
areas: sex, party political identification, and
declared vote in the EU referendum' (7) [male,
conservatives and leave voters] [again actual
figures e.g. 18% versus 34% prejudiced for
remainers as leavers]. They did not find a
statistically significant relationship with 'level
of education, social class, income, age and
region' although there was a strong association
between these and attitudes to immigration.
There has been an increase in sensitivity to
prejudice, but it does not follow that people who
describe themselves as racially prejudiced are
doing so incorrectly [avoids the issue nicely]
.The 2014 European social survey also asked
questions about race — for example whether some
races or ethnic groups are born less intelligent:
18% of UK respondents said yes, 'while a clear
majority rejected this idea' (8) — 'a substantial
proportion of the public'. 44 per cent of
respondents thought some races or ethnic groups
are born harder working, and older people and
people with lower levels of educational attainment
were more likely to answer yes. Gender and income
were also statistically more likely with beliefs
that some races and ethnic groups are born less
intelligent but not that they were
hard-working.[NB this EU survey found prejudice
inthe UK was higher only than in Malta]
While there is not the same downward trend as we
see with other social attitudes, the focus of
prejudice may be changing. Respondents were more
likely to perceive prejudice in others than in
themselves. There is a 'significant and steady
decline in the percentage of respondents who say
that most white people in Britain and they
themselves would mind a lot or mind a little if a
close relative married someone who is black or
Asian. [Down to about 60% for most people and 20%
personally]. More people said they would mind,
then described themselves as racially prejudiced.
It was worse when asked if they would marry a
person who is Muslim.
There is still evidence [not here there
isn't] that perceptions of black pupils
among teachers or employers can have a negative
impact, and there may be 'institutionalised racial
prejudice within the criminal justice system [but
not based on their survey data].
Overall 'inequalities associated with race are
endemic in UK society, across income, education,
work, health, and criminal justice [not just]
extreme or overt forms of racism… All the more
distant, impersonal concept of institutional
racism' (12).
[This really is simple positivism. The questions
are banal. What is meant by 'you'— you personally
or 'one' [sometimes that is specified]? How on
earth can respondents seriously say what most
white British people would think? Is the question
about Muslims or black people that they actually
know or black and Muslim people in general? What
about the ludicrous generalisations of the last
bit? How were they to define races or ethnic
groups, or terms like hard-working or intelligent?
How reliable is the staff on party allegiance or
indeed referendum vote for that matter? Does
everyone agree on the difference between very
prejudiced and little prejudiced, and what an
earth are the surveys doing lumping those two
together in their data? Other dodgy
aggregates include the data on 26% of the
repondents being 'prejudiced' (but only 1%
'very'). How on earth can people judge whether
there is more or less racial prejudice in the
whole of Britain than there was five years ago?]
|
|